Major Decision

From our September/October 2009 issue: He went 159-0 in college. Won an Olympic gold medal on his first try. So what’s Cael Sanderson doing for an encore? Trying to lead the Nittany Lions to an NCAA team wrestling title.

head shot of Cael Sanderson by Cardoni

The way Cael Sanderson’s father sees it, his son was just figuring out some way to cope. It’s what any beginning wrestler has to do, especially one with two older brothers.

Cody, the oldest, was big and strong, a bruiser. Cole, brother No. 2, had impeccable technique. “Cael had a hard time with Cole because Cole was slick,” says Cael’s father, Steve. “And he didn’t like wrestling with Cody because he got pounded. So he found a different direction to go. It wasn’t wrong. It was just different.”

At first, that meant rolling the opposite way from the rest of the kids during drills. Eventually, that turned into wrestling from his back, a position most wrestlers avoid because it could mean an instant end to the match—being pinned. Not Sanderson.

“I want to do things better than anybody,” he says. “You have to look for ways to make that happen. There’s a lot of ways to get the job done. You’ve just got to create some angles.”

So don’t ever look for Sanderson to take the expected route. Too many people there.

He stands alone as the only undefeated four-time NCAA champion in history. His record at Iowa State: 159-0.

Even though he was just entering the prime of his competitive career, he never competed again after winning a gold medal at the 2004 Athens Olympics. He was only 25, and even his father thought he’d be better at the 2008 Games. But Sanderson got a coaching job, and he retired from competition.

And although he was seemingly rooted at Iowa State both by family ties and by 12 years as a competitor, assistant coach, and head coach, five months ago he stunned the wrestling world by taking the head coaching job at Penn State. His goal: to lead the Nittany Lions to their first NCAA team title since 1953.

 

black and white photo of Penn State's 1953 NCAA title-winning wrestling team by Penn State Sports Information
HOME-MAT ADVANTAGE: Penn State won its only NCAA title in 1953, when the tournament was at Rec Hall and Charlie Speidel '39, '41 MS H&HD (far left) was the coach. Penn State Sports Information.

 

“And after we do win a national championship, our goal’s going to be another one,” he says. “Two in a row, three in a row. We’ll keep raising the bar.”

Bold words, to be sure. But in hiring him, Penn State made a bold move.

 

Sanderson is an icon. He is the only wrestler to appear on a Wheaties box. Sports Illustrated ranked his college career the No. 2 most impressive achievement in the history of college sports (behind only Ohio State track star Jesse Owens setting four world records in one day). Sports Illustrated for Women named Sanderson one of its 50 sexiest athletes. Five years after his last competitive match, he is still one of the sport’s best-known athletes.

As a coach, he has not reached such heights. But he was successful in three seasons at Iowa State­­—his teams never finished lower than fifth at the NCAA championships—and Penn State athletic director Tim Curley ’76 H&HD, ’78 MEd Edu says, “We think he’s got the same potential for his coaching career that he did for his wrestling career.”

He’s going to need it. Because winning an NCAA team wrestling title is one of the most difficult feats in college sports.

No other sport has been dominated by so few teams. Oklahoma State has won 33 titles; Iowa, 22. And in the past two decades, only one other school, Minnesota, has claimed a team title. Says Jay Hammond, official historian for the National Wrestling Hall of Fame, “It’s extraordinary, it really is.”

Penn State, although it is considered among the sport’s elite, has only that one team title, won 56 long years ago. And while Hammond isn’t taking anything away from that team, he notes that those Nittany Lions had every single thing go their way. Nationals were on their home mat. Oklahoma's best wrestler, the 1952 tournament's Outstanding Wrestler, was injured. And Oklahoma State was in a rebuilding year.

Although the Nittany Lions haven’t won again, they have been in the hunt. The program has 12 top-three finishes. Eighteen individual NCAA champions, three of whom won two titles. Penn State wrestlers have earned All-America honors 163 times.

Recently, however, some of the program’s luster has faded. Troy Sunderland ’93 EMS, a three-time All-American and two-time NCAA finalist, resigned in April after the team finished 17th. Sunderland’s 11 seasons as coach included some bright spots­—a third-place finish in 2008, a tie for fourth in his first season, 1999, and two individual champions.

But there’s a sense that given Penn State’s advantages, the team should be better.

That’s because Pennsylvania wrestlers dominate at the NCAA championships, but not all of them are competing for their home state schools. In 2009, for instance, of the 80 All-Americans, 11 grew up in Pennsylvania. Only one, freshman Quentin Wright, was wearing a Penn State uniform.

Plus, the University has some of the sport’s best facilities—and some deep-pocketed donors. The wrestling program receives more donor support than any Penn State sport except football, and in 2005, it opened the Lorenzo Wrestling Complex, a 24,000-foot training facility considered among the nation’s best because of its size and scope, which includes a practice room, weight room, and locker room. Named for former coach Rich Lorenzo ’68, ’75 MS Agr, the complex was paid for mostly by former wrestlers who want to see the sport’s profile grow.

Hiring Sanderson is another step.

“Certainly when you have a world-class coach with a world-class training facility and a world-class university, those three combined send a pretty powerful message that we are serious about wrestling,” Curley says. “We want to succeed at the highest level.”

Sanderson­—at least as an athlete—knows how to get there.

 

Cael Sanderson wrestling at Iowa State, photo by Tim Rose/AP

IN THE SPOTLIGHT: Sanderson was more comfortable on the mat in 2002 en route to his fourth NCAA title (above) than on the medal stand at the 2004 Olympics (below). Tim Rose/AP and Ricardo Mazalan/AP.

Cael Sanderson on the 2004 Olympics medal stand wearing gold medal and holding laurel wreath and flowers, photo by Ricardo Mazalan/AP

Sanderson can’t remember life without wrestling. The sport tends to run in families, and among his first memories is attending his grandfather’s wrestling camp. Grandpa Sanderson didn’t compete in wrestling, but he learned the sport because his son Steve did.

Steve Sanderson competed at 134 pounds for Brigham Young University, just missing All-America honors. When he and his wife, Debbie, had children, there was no question but that they would get involved in the sport. (Cael and his wife, Kelly, feel the same way. Their 2-year-old son, Tate, will eventually wrestle one day, and Cael likes to say, half seriously, “Wrestling will fix any mistakes we make as parents.”)

Wrestling brought the Sandersons close. When Cody, the oldest, chose Iowa State, there was little doubt that Cole and Cael would follow. The three brothers even shared an apartment. (And their youngest brother, Cyler, also wrestled at Iowa State, although the Cyclones released him his last year of eligibility so he could follow Cael to Penn State.)

Cael Sanderson arrived at Iowa State in 1997 as one of the nation’s top recruits. He had won four state titles at Wasatch High School in Heber City, Utah, where his father coached. Mentally, he was ready for collegiate competition. Steve Sanderson had instilled the same attitude in all of his wrestlers, especially his four sons. Score as many points as possible. Never let up. Always be on the attack.

 “We don’t compete to win, we compete to fight,” Cael Sanderson says. “It all comes down to a fundamental belief—what’s your goal when you step on the mat? It’s to give your very best effort, and take the win or the loss or whatever comes after that.”

Sanderson loves to expound on that philosophy. He writes a blog on his official website, www.caelsanderson.com, that touches on everything from the favorite of his mother’s pies to Benjamin Franklin’s “Plan of Conduct” to the nation’s politics, but his longest and most impassioned posts talk about competition.:“Everyone likes to win. Liking to win is  not much of a motivator. Enjoying winning is not enough to force someone to make difficult sacrifices and/or changes.”

Despite that background and mentality, however, he wasn’t physically mature enough for collegiate wrestling when he arrived at Iowa State. So he redshirted for his first season, using the time to get stronger. He thought about what would be his best effort, and he came up with a goal that only one person, Oklahoma State’s Pat Smith, had ever achieved: Win four NCAA titles. Some of the biggest names in the sport had fallen short, including legendary Iowa coach Dan Gable, who wrestled at Iowa State and lost in the final match of his college career.

Sanderson didn’t worry about any of that. From the first match of his freshman year, he was the aggressor. He won three titles at 184 pounds, and even though he moved up a weight class and was a small 197-pounder as a senior, he dominated.

He was known for his long arms, for his speed. He could hit his signature move, the ankle pick (taking an opponent down by destabilizing his ankle) with either hand or either foot. He used it with abandon. “I had to make my opponents not want to wrestle me again,” he says. “If they saw me again at nationals, I wanted them to know that I was going to be coming after them for seven minutes. You want to build up that reputation right away, that you’re the bad draw.”

When the final whistle blew, the aggression was gone. Sanderson rarely even pumped his fist in triumph. (On the medal stand at the Olympics, he fidgeted, unsure of what to do with the giant U.S. flags given to him by spectators, and removed his laurel wreath because he was afraid it would fall. He told The Washington Post, “I’m not good with props.”)

Sanderson’s demeanor contrasted with some of the sport’s other legends, such as Gable and Oklahoma State coach John Smith, a two-time Olympic gold medalist (and the older brother of four-time champion Pat), who were known for their swagger.

“Cael didn’t go 159-0 without being competitive in a somewhat underkey manner,” says Hammond, the wrestling historian, “but I don’t think anyone would accuse him of being a Type A personality.”

His family disagrees. “Oh, I think he controls his outward appearance and emotions pretty well,” Sanderson’s father says. “But if you get close to him, look in his eyes. What you’ll see there will scare you sometimes.”

 

Curley took a close look, and he liked what he saw. He’s not the only one.

Last season, Penn State had about 1,000 wrestling season-ticket holders. In the first three months after Sanderson was hired, 500 more people put down a deposit on season tickets—even before the schedule was announced.

Some of those highly touted Pennsylvania high schoolers have already decided to stay home. Two wrestlers ranked No. 1 nationally n their respective weight classes, twins Andrew and Dylan Alton of Central Mountain High School, verbally committed to Penn State weeks after Sanderson was hired. They will arrive on campus in 2010.

Getting that talent won’t be easy. Pennsylvania has 14 Division I wrestling teams, more than any other state. “Probably there’s more wrestling talent within 300 miles of State College than anyplace else in the country,” Hammond says. “But there’s also more Division I schools competing in wrestling within a 300-mile radius than anywhere else.”

Sanderson calls keeping Pennsylvania kids home “one of our main challenges as a staff.” But he wants to cast a wide net, and he’s already made inroads on that front. The nation’s top-ranked overall recruit, David Miller of suburban Dayton, Ohio, was released from his commitment to Iowa State and followed Sanderson to Penn State. He’ll begin classes in the fall while taking a redshirt year.

This season’s team will be largely the same as the team that finished 17th at NCAAS last season, but Sanderson says observers will see a difference right away. That’s a necessity, he says, to make sure that he’s setting the right tone for the program.

“What I want to see and what I coach is this: I want the guys to wrestle every second,” Sanderson says. “I want guys who wrestle an entertaining style. You need to feel like it’s a loss if you beat a guy by one when you should beat a guy by eight.

“That’s what’s going to pack the stadium, the coliseum. Having a solid team. That’s what brings pride to the school. Having a national champion or an All-American is great, but winning the team title, that’s what it’s all about.”