Michael Mann and ‘Climategate’

December 3, 2009

The news last week that e-mail exchanges between prominent climate scientists had been hacked and made public — news that, probably not coincidentally, came a couple of weeks before the upcoming international climate conference in Copenhagen — has been overshadowed only by “news” about Tiger Woods’ personal life. Language in some of the e-mails seems to imply that scientists have hidden or altered climate change data. And a Penn State professor has been near the center of it.

Michael E. Mann, professor of meteorology and director of the University’s Earth System Science Center, is one of two climate scientists whose work and reputation are being questioned after the e-mail leak. Mann — one of five Penn State faculty members who participated in our climate change roundtable back in 2007 — has long been a leading voice among those pointing to man-made CO2 emissions as the primary cause of global warming. He’s one of the scientists involved in the Web site realclimate.org. And he’s also a favorite target of those who don’t buy the idea of man-made warming — “skeptics” or “deniers,” depending on your point of view.

Plenty of blog space has been taken up on the topic since the story broke. And while the story continues to develop — a few days ago, the College of Earth and Mineral Sciences released a statement (which you can read in PDF form here) announcing it would, per University policy, “look into the matter further” — we’ve found a few stories that offer a reasoned take on the controversy to date, including this one from Science Magazine, and this from Bloomberg News. You also can read Mann’s own explanation of some of the e-mails in question.

Ryan Jones, senior editor

Entry Filed under: College of Earth and Mineral Sciences, The Penn Stater magazine. Tags: , , , .

6 Comments Add your own

  • 1. More on ‘Climategate’ «  |  December 11, 2009 at 11:59 am

    [...] I was interested to see them weigh in yesterday on “Climategate,” the brouhaha involving several climate scientists (including Penn State faculty member [...]

  • 2. anon  |  December 16, 2009 at 11:54 am

    bloomberg is misspelled.

  • 3. Ryan Jones  |  December 16, 2009 at 3:20 pm

    So it was, and now fixed. Thanks for the catch.

  • [...] Yesterday we noticed some referrals from pennstatemag.com to blogs about Michael Mann, so we followed the link back and found a post on Michael Mann and Climategate. [...]

  • 5. Ron Land  |  February 15, 2010 at 12:23 am

    Having personally read the complete text of the reports “Climategate Analysis” and “Surface Temperature Records” released by the Science and Public Policy Institute (available at http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/), it seems there is much to be looked into by the University w.r.t. the validity and integrity of Dr. Mann’s work. I would hope an announcement of some kind would be forthcoming sooner rather than later.

  • 6. JohnB  |  February 16, 2010 at 4:00 pm

    The PSU will, of course, find nothing. It is an internal investigation which are designed to cover things up. What is PSU going to say “We screwed up but succeeded in getting millions of dollars from trumped up data”? If the AJ of Pennsylvania undertakes a REAL investigation I will take it more seriously.

Leave a Comment

hidden

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Subscribe
      via RSS
      by email

Recent Posts

Bloggers

Tina Hay
Posts | Bio
Amy Guyer
Posts | Bio
Ryan Jones
Posts | Bio
Jessie Knuth
Posts | Bio
Barbara Marshall
Posts | Bio
Julie Nelson
Posts | Bio
Carole Otypka
Posts | Bio
Lori Shontz
Posts | Bio

Tags

Aaron Maybin Associated Press Barbara Bird Beaver Stadium Ben Feller Bryce Jordan Center CASE Central Pennsylvania Festival of the Arts Centre Daily Times Chip Kidd Coquese Washington Daily Collegian Ed DeChellis Eisenhower Auditorium ESPN Facebook Francisca Halamajowa iPhone Jay Paterno Joe Paterno Judy Maltz Michael Weinreb Neil Rudel Newsweek New York Times NIT Nittany Lion Shrine No. 4 Street of Our Lady NPR Old Main Paternoville Philadelphia Inquirer Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Richie Sherman Rose Bowl Russ Rose Steve McCurry Talor Battle THON Twitter USA Today Vicki Glembocki Washington Post women's volleyball WPSU

Categories

Alumni Association Campus events Campus issues College of Arts and Architecture College of Communications College of the Liberal Arts Eberly College of Science Famous Penn Staters Hintz Family Alumni Center Joe Paterno Nittany Lion basketball Other Penn State sports Penn State alumni Penn State faculty research Penn State football Penn State in the news Penn State students Penn State traditions The Penn Stater magazine University Park campus

Archives

Sites We Like

   Penn State Alumni Association
   OnwardState—a student-run blog
   Penn State Class of 2010
   Blunt Force Mama—Vicki Glembocki ’93, ’02g
   Citizen Mom—Amy Zurzola Quinn ’94
   Penn State Press
   Steve McCurry's Blog—Steve McCurry ’74
   Good is Dead—Chip Kidd ’86
   Today in the Sky—Ben Mutzabaugh ’97
   Seldom Scene—local photographer Nick Sloff ’92
   Homegrown Happy Valley—Michele Marchetti ’95
   Better Days Ahead—Erin Strout ’97
   Maxwell Kruger—great photography by a 2009 Penn State grad